Mattress Firmness Guide

Mike Stownel Mike Stownel
Firmness guide

Finding the perfect mattress that’s not too soft but not too firm can be more easily done with an understanding of mattress firmness. The findings of our comprehensive mattresses firmness guide will teach you about the four types of mattress firmness, which companies provide the best mattresses with free delivery, the recommended firmness for different mattress models, along with the pros and cons that surround the various levels of mattress firmness.

Mattress Firmness Guide

#1. Saatva - The classic mattress has one of three degrees of firmness, including Plush Soft (3), Luxury Firm (5-7), and Firm (8).

#2. Puffy - There are two different mattress firmnesses: medium-firm (6-8) and medium-plush (5-7), while mattresses can be memory foam or a hybrid.

#3. Nectar - Nectar splits the middle, with a medium-firm mattress firmness (6.5), to provide an excellent balance between support and comfort.

#4. Dreamcloudsleep - Medium-firm (6.5), also referred to as luxury-firm, is the luxury-level mattress firmness offered by the DreamCloud Sleep brand.

#5. Casper - Casper leverages medium-firm (5-6), the most popular mattress comfort, while the Nova Hybrid mattress has an extra plush top.

Our Top Product Picks

Other Mattresses Brands

What Does it Mean?

Depending on a sleeper’s body weight, preferred sleeping positions, personal and partner preferences, a mattress firmness level can quickly point you in the right direction to a mattress that is best suited for you.

What Choice on the Market - Firmness Scale

Mattress firmness is graded on a scale of 1 through 10. Most shoppers will notice mattresses labeled as soft, medium-soft, medium-firm, or firm in retail. Sleepers that weigh more may have to use medium-firm to firm mattresses instead of soft and medium-soft because those beds are constructed with additional support features.

How to Choose the Best One

Our guide highlights the best mattress companies in the industry, while our firmness chart embedded below will help you quickly narrow down which mattress firmness is optimal for you.

Pros & Cons

 

Soft Mattresses

  • Optimal for Lightweight Sleepers
  • Lightweight, plusher, and cloud-like
  • Best for side or combination sleepers
  • Not suitable for heavier sleepers
  • Provides more surface motion disturbance
  • Less postural and spinal support

Medium-Soft Mattresses

  • Suitable for side and sleeping couples
  • The body feels elevated from the mattress
  • Ample hugging and contouring
  • Not as soft or plush
  • Not ideal for stomach sleepers
  • Less postural support

Medium-Firm Mattresses

  • Suitable for back and stomach sleepers
  • Most popular mattress firmness level
  • Decreased motion surface disturbances
  • Not nearly as soft
  • Provides less contouring
  • Not made for lightweight sleepers

Firm Mattresses

  • Suitable for back, stomach, and heavier sleepers
  • Like sleeping “on top” of the mattress, not in it
  • Has better response and more resistance than soft/medium-soft
  • Not as soft are other mattress firmness grades
  • Provides little contouring or hugging
  • Not as versatile as more lightweight mattresses

Mattress Firmness Chart

The following chart will show the four types of mattress firmness, their firmness rating from a scale of 1 to 10, what kinds of sleepers are ideal for each firmness level, and how the mattress feels.

Our Top Product Picks

1
Saatva
  • 180-night trial
  • 15-year warranty
  • Free white glove delivery
  • Durable and from eco-friendly materials
Save $200 Price from $799
Visit Site →

saatva.com

2
Puffy
  • 101-night trial
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Free, no-contact delivery
Save $300 Price from $795
Visit Site →

puffy.com

3
Nectar
  • Forever warranty
  • 365-night sleep trial
  • Free, no-contact delivery
  • $499 to $1,299 @ 0% APR
Save $399 Price from $499
Visit Site →

nectarsleep.com

4
Dreamcloudsleep
  • Lifetime warranty
  • 365-night sleep trial
  • Free shipping and returns
  • $599 to 1,099 @ 0% APR
Save $200 Price from $899
Visit Site →

dreamcloudsleep.com

5
Casper
  • 100-night trial
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • Free, no-contact delivery
  • 90% of sleepers experience less back pain
Save 10% Price from $595
Visit Site →

casper.com

1. Saatva

Price Range: $799 to $1,899. Offer: Get 200$ off and FREE glove delivery

Trial period: 180-nights

Warranty: 15 years

Financing : 0% APR, Klarna

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Saatva

Saatva mattresses have one of three firmness levels: Plush soft (3), Luxury Firm (5-7), and Firm (8). Preferred by 82% of customers, the Luxury Firm Saatva mattress provides ample uplifting support with an equal balance of support. Side sleepers who prefer extra contouring or a more soft, cushiony feel gravitate towards the Saatva Plush Soft classic mattress

Saatva
Saatva

Premium Materials. White Glove Delivery, 24/7 Customer Support. Try It For 180 Nights

Save $200 Price from $799

2. Puffy

Price Range: $795 to $1,995. Offer: $300 OFF + 2 FREE PILLOWS

Trial period: 101-nights

Warranty: as long as you own the mattress

Financing : 0% APR, Klarna

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy

American-made, Puffy provides three types of mattresses that each come with varying levels of firmness. The Puffy 10” mattress provides 3-layers of support and has a medium-firmness of 6 to 8. Puffy most popular mattress, the Lux mattress, has 4-layers of support and a medium firmness rating of 5 to 7. The Royal mattress has 5-layers and a medium firmness rating of 5 out of 10.

Puffy
Puffy

Lifetime Warranty, Free Return. Up To $300 Off. Try It Now

Save $300 Price from $795

3. Nectar

Price Range: $499 to $1,799. Offer: $399 Of Accessories Included With Every Mattress

Trial period: 365-nights

Warranty: as long as you own the mattress

Financing : 0% APR, Affirm, Splitit

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Nectar

Over 1 million Nectar mattresses have found their way into American family homes. Striving to be America’s Most Comfortable Mattress, Nectar provides two types of mattresses that each come with a mattress firmness rating of 6.5 (medium-firm). The Nectar Lush mattress features dual-action cooling, a lofty feel, superior support, and minimizes motion surface disturbances.

Nectar
Nectar

Free Shipping & Returns, Financing Available. Try It Risk-Free For A Full Year

Save $399 Price from $499

4. Dreamcloud Sleep

Price Range: $799 to $1,599. Offer: $200 Off + $399 In Accessories Included!

Trial period: 365-nights

Warranty: as long as you own the mattress

Financing : 0% APR, Affirm

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Dreamcloudsleep

Dreamcloud Sleep provides two types of mattresses that each come with a medium-firm mattress firmness rating of 6.5. The DreamCloud Premier mattress offers 6-layers for comfort, has a cashmere blend euro top, and cooling characteristics from the gel-infused memory foam. The Luxury Hybrid mattress has 5-layers for comfort and pressure-relief support.

Dreamcloudsleep
Dreamcloudsleep

Free Shipping Within 14 - 21 Business Days. Try Our 100% Risk-Free

Save $200 Price from $899

5. Casper

Price Range: $595 to $2,995. Offer: Save up to $940 on select mattress

Trial period: 100-nights

Warranty: 10 years

Financing : 0% APR, Affirm

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper

Casper is the #1 Bed in a box brand in the US and provides three types of mattresses that come with varying levels of firmness. The Casper Nova Hybrid mattress has a medium-soft firmness of 4 while both the Casper Wave Hybrid mattress and the Casper Original mattress reflect a medium-firm firmness of 5 to 7.

Casper
Casper

Try Your New Dream Mattress. Take A Test Nap

Save 10% Price from $595

Mattress Firmness Types

Soft (1 - 2)

Composed of ultra-lightweight yet durable materials, soft mattresses will allow the body to sink deeply. There aren’t as many soft-rated mattresses due to a lack of demand and how it is most suitable for sleepers under 130 pounds, which doesn’t include the majority of the adult population. Often compared to sleeping on a cloud, soft mattresses deeply hug sleepers and make them feel as if they are sleeping “in” the mattress instead of on it.

Medium-Soft (3 - 4)

Not as cloud-like, medium-soft mattresses provide plenty of body-hugging and contouring for an exchange in softness. Sleepers will feel more raised on this mattress while this mattress is suitable for sleeping couples, lightweight side sleepers, and combination sleepers.

Medium-Firm (5 - 7)

The most popular go-to mattress firmness would be medium-firm. Medium-firm mattresses are known to provide the perfect balance between contouring and firmness. Additionally, there is less sinkage and conforming, while this mattress firmness is suitable for nearly every kind of sleeper.

Firm (8 - 10)

Firm mattresses have a significantly harder surface than soft to medium-soft mattresses. There is minimum hug or contouring, while sleepers may feel like they are sleeping on top of the bed instead of in it. It provides superior support and is best suited for back or stomach sleepers.

The Bottom Line

The battle between mattress firmness and support almost always boils down to the personal preferences of a sleeper. Knowing the four types of mattress firmness and your sleep preferences will significantly aid you in your quest to find the best mattress for you. While the most popular bedding choice is medium-firm mattresses, medium-soft and firm mattresses are also quite common and can cater to a broad demographic of sleepers.

FAQ

What are the four types of mattress firmness?
The four types of mattress firmness include soft (1-2), medium-soft (3 - 4), medium-firm (5 - 7), and firm (8 - 10).
Which mattress firmness is best for lightweight sleepers?
Lightweight sleepers will want mattresses that have a firmness rating of soft to medium-soft.
Which mattress firmness is best for heavy sleepers?
Medium-firm and firm mattresses are best for heavier sleepers.
Which mattress firmness is best for back sleepers?
Mattresses that are medium-firm to firm are best for back sleepers.
Which mattress firmness grade is the most popular?
The medium-firm mattress grade is the most popular mattress firmness.

Other Companies

Kolcraft
4.5
Read Review →
Englander
4.5
Read Review →
Mozaic
4.0
Read Review →
AmeriSleep
4.9
Read Review →
Avocado
4.5
Read Review →

All reviews

Written by: Mike Stownel

Staff Writer - Researcher

Mike is an experienced Researcher and Writer. Now his challenge is to test, compare, and review the best sleep products like mattresses, pillows and sheets

Add New Comment