Crib Mattress Review

Mike Stownel Mike Stownel
Naturepedic - The Best Crib mattress
4.7 (18)

Save 10%

Checkout Now
Crib mattress

There isn’t anything you wouldn’t do for your little one; trust us, we understand. That’s why we’re here today. To help you find the safest, most supportive crib mattress online. Our honest review will answer your questions, address need-to-know insights, and help you choose the best crib mattress. Let us help guide you in this pivotal moment and make a choice that’s as important to you as it is close to your heart.

How Does it Work?

Crib mattresses provide support and comfort to newborns during the vital stages of infancy.

How to Use

Generally, crib mattresses are found in nurseries or the parent’s bedroom, although every household’s parenting style differs.

Benefits of Using

Here are four reasons why your newborn should sleep on a crib mattress:

  • Comfort - Ample firmness and comfort for optimal support.
  • Protection - Waterproof and stain-proof barriers simplify clean-up.
  • Technology - Cooling overnight comfort and odor repelling.
  • Convenience - Crib mattress pads are easy to clean (machine washable).

How to Choose the Best?

We highlight some of the best and most affordable crib mattresses below.

1. Naturepedic

Price Range: $649 to $9999. Offer: 10% off for all mattress!

Trial period: 90-nights

Warranty: 20-years

Financing : Affirm

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Naturepedic

Naturepedic has two organic crib mattresses, the classic and breathable. The Classic ($259+) and the Breathable ($349+) are lightweight, feature 150 to 252 coil support, and offer 2-stage dual firmness. The Classic crib mattress provides a wipe-clean waterproof surface, whereas the Breathable renders a washable, breathable cover. Mini and oval crib mattresses are available, while all Naturepedic crib mattresses are certified organic and non-toxic.

Naturepedic
Naturepedic

Over 15 Years Experience In Organic Mattresses. 2-3 Business Days Shipping. Order Now

Save 10% Price from $649

2. Sealy

Sealy

Sealy offers over 50 baby crib mattresses between $59.99 to $199.99. The Sealy Butterfly Collection has the most popular crib and toddler mattresses that are waterproof and breathable and cost between $99.99 to $109.99. Sealy crib mattresses’ features include cooling gel, cotton cushioning, memory foam, are lightweight, and are available in hybrid, foam core, and spring mattresses.

Sealy
Sealy

Feel The Sealy Difference For Yourself!

Save 35% Price from $730

3. Serta

Serta

Serta crib and toddler mattresses ($149.99 - $199.99) are American-made, have a waterproof cover, and 50-year warranties. For a spring-free crib mattress, Serta’s iComfort Harmony Crib and Toddler Mattress ($199.99) is entirely EverCool Memory Foam. This breathable memory foam dissipates heat and is GreenGuard Gold Certified for quality assurance. Serta’s Tranquility line provides spring-supported crib mattresses.

Serta
Serta

Try A Serta Mattress Before You Commit And Save Up To $1,000!

Save $300 Price from $299

4. Tempur Pedic

Tempur Pedic

The Tempur-Dream 2-Star Crib Mattress ($499.99) reduces motion transfers, safely responds to your child’s personalized comfort and support preferences, and provides pressure-relieving material. This crib mattress has a waterproof silky smooth fabric cover, a 360-degree zip-off design, premium memory foam, and is air and chemical-tested for product integrity.

Tempur Pedic
Tempur Pedic

Tempur Pedic Mattress Materials Help You Fall Asleep Faster And Stay Sleep Longer.

Save 30% Price from $1,699

5. Lullaby Earth

Lullaby Earth

Lullaby Earth crib mattress collection ($169.99 to $259.99) is free of flame retardants and offers superior breathability. For the Mini Crib mattress ($199.99), advantages include a lifetime warranty, a 30-day money-back guarantee, and free shipping and returns. All crib mattresses are free of harmful chemicals, are easy to clean, and are eco-friendly.

Lullaby Earth
Lullaby Earth

Lullaby Earth's mission is to create the safest and healthiest mattresses at prices everyone can afford.

Save 20% Price from $796

6. Dream On Me

Dream On Me

Dream On Me crib mattresses are hypoallergenic, have an easy-to-clean waterproof and stain-resistant cover, and costs between $39.99 to $169.99. All mattresses are JPMA and GreenGuard Gold Certified, have a 10-year limited warranty and are manufactured in the United States. Some Dream On Me crib mattresses is two-sided and extra firm.

Dream On Me
Dream On Me

The biggest and most trusted baby care brand in USA

Save $50 Price from $39.99

7. Kolcraft

Kolcraft

Kolcraft offers affordable crib mattresses that range between $39.99 to $89.99. Their crib mattress lineup concerns mostly innerspring mattresses that contain innerspring coils. However, the Kolcraft Fresh Start PolyFoam Crib Mattress ($89.99) is made entirely from a hypoallergenic polyfoam and has a waterproof and stain-resistant cover.

Kolcraft Review
Kolcraft Review

Buy Kolcraft Mattress With A 25 Year Warranty On Workmanship And Materials!

Save 20% Price from $39.99

8. Sleep Moonlight

Sleep Moonlight

Sleep Moonlight 5” dual-sided crib mattress supports newborns and toddlers and has a flexible performance fabric cover. The Little Dreamer Crib Mattress ($196.99) is plush for toddlers on one side and firm for babies on the other. Finance with Affirm at 0% APR to pay only $68/month and get up to 10% OFF.

Sleep Moonlight Review
Sleep Moonlight Review

From crib to king, it`s with you every night of the way. Try A Free And Fast Shipping Sitewide!

Save 10% Price from $119.99

The Bottom Line

As a guardian, there is little that you wouldn’t do to protect your little bundle of joy. That’s why we’ve made it easy for you by sharing the cream of the crop so you can choose a crib mattress that’s suitable for your newest addition. When choosing a mattress that’s safe for your little one, make sure those mattresses are hypoallergenic and meet purity standards - no toddler should sleep on a toxic bed.

FAQ

What are the dimensions of a standard crib mattress?
According to the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008, the Federal government regulates the crib for all standard crib mattresses, with the minimum size being: 27 ¼” x 51 ⅝”. All North American crib mattresses must measure between 51 ⅝” to 53” in length and 21 ¼” to 28” in width.
What’s the average thickness of a crib mattress to be?
Most crib and toddler mattresses have a thickness between 4” to 6.”
Is it OK to reuse a crib mattress?
Old crib mattresses can settle, become soft and uneven. Suppose you purchased a crib mattress for an older sibling, and it still appears in good condition. In that case, it may be reusable, granted that it fits correctly, has good firmness and resiliency, and maintains frame integrity.
Written by: Mike Stownel

Senior Sleep Health and Mattress Technology Expert

Mike Stownel is a seasoned sleep health and mattress technology expert with over a decade of rich experience. He previously served as a Sleep Wellness Advisor for numerous boutique mattress manufacturers, where he played a crucial role in product development and customer education. Mike also worked as a Consultant for several start-up sleep tech companies, contributing to innovative sleep solution strategies.

 

His deep understanding of mattress technology and sleep science, combined with practical industry experience, positions him as a trusted authority. Mike`s insights, rooted in both science and market trends, offer invaluable guidance for achieving optimal sleep health.

 

Add New Comment